The Age Advantage in Success: Beating the Odds

in #hive-1159004 days ago

Mulan

The Relative Age Effect (RAE) is a powerful force in football, shaping careers before players even realize it. For decades, youth academies have unintentionally favored early-born players, giving them better coaching, more opportunities, and a higher chance of going pro. Meanwhile, late-born players—despite having just as much talent—often get left behind.

But while the system is stacked against them, some late-born players have still managed to beat the odds.

How do they do it? And what can young players, coaches, and clubs learn from their success?

The Few Who Overcame the Relative Age Effect

Even though the data shows that early-born players dominate football, some late-born players have broken through—often through a mix of determination, adaptability, and the right opportunities at the right time.

Some of the biggest names in world football were actually born in the later months of the year, including:

  • Lionel Messi (June) – Small, late-blooming, and almost overlooked before Barcelona took a chance on him.
  • Kylian Mbappé (December) – Faced early struggles but was given a supportive development path that allowed him to flourish.
  • Luka Modrić (September) – Considered too weak and undersized for years, yet became one of the best midfielders of his generation.
  • Antoine Griezmann (March) – Rejected by multiple academies for being too small but later thrived in Spain’s youth system.
  • Dries Mertens (December) – Benefited from Belgium’s Future Project, which ensured late-born players had a fair chance to develop.

Each of these players faced extra challenges due to their birth month. Some were overlooked by academies, while others had to compensate for their smaller size and lack of early physical development. But they all had one thing in common: they found ways to adapt and refuse to give up.

How Do Late-Born Players Beat the System?

For players born later in the year, the path to success is often more difficult—but not impossible. Those who make it tend to develop certain key traits:

1. Resilience and Mental Toughness

Late-born players often have to fight harder to prove themselves. Being overlooked from an early age can be frustrating, but those who persist develop a stronger mentality—one that allows them to push through setbacks and rejections.

Modrić was told he was too weak to play professionally. Instead of quitting, he trained harder and proved doubters wrong.
Griezmann was rejected by multiple French academies. He moved to Spain, where he was finally given a chance to develop.
These players didn’t just rely on talent; they built the mental toughness needed to survive in a system that was against them.

2. Adaptability and Intelligence

Since late-born players often lack physical advantages early on, they are forced to rely on technical skills, intelligence, and creativity to compete with stronger opponents.

  • Messi had to develop his low center of gravity, agility, and quick decision-making to compensate for his smaller size.
  • Mbappé focused on perfecting his dribbling and movement, allowing him to outplay bigger defenders.
  • Modrić became a master at positioning and ball control, making up for his lack of physical strength.

Because they cannot dominate physically at a young age, late-born players often become smarter, more technical, and more strategic on the pitch—which can give them an advantage in the long run.

3. Finding the Right Development Path

Many late-born players struggle in traditional youth academies, but some succeed by finding alternative paths that allow them to grow at their own pace.

  • Messi left Argentina for Barcelona, where the club invested in his development despite his small size.
  • Modrić started at smaller Croatian clubs, where he was given time to develop before moving to bigger teams.
  • Mertens benefited from Belgium’s Future Project, which ensured that late-born players got equal opportunities.

For late-born players, being in the right environment is crucial. If an academy system is not working for them, finding a club or country that values technical development over physical size can make all the difference.

What Can Football Do to Help Late-Born Players?

While some players manage to overcome the Relative Age Effect, many others never get the chance. If football wants to be a truly fair sport, more needs to be done to help late-born players develop.

Some of the best solutions include:

  • More “Future Projects” like Belgium’s: Shadow teams for late-born players can ensure that they are not left behind too early.
  • Biological age classification: Grouping players based on their physical and mental maturity rather than their birth year can create a more level playing field.
  • Better scouting methods: Coaches and scouts should be trained to recognize potential, rather than just selecting the biggest and strongest kids.
  • Flexible academy structures: Allowing late-blooming players extra time to develop before making final decisions on their future.

In Conclusion

The Relative Age Effect has shaped football in ways most people never realize. While early-born players get a natural advantage, late-born players are often forced to take a harder, more uncertain path. However, as players like Messi, Mbappé, and Modrić have shown, success is still possible—but it requires resilience, adaptability, and often a bit of luck in finding the right opportunities.

The football world is slowly waking up to this hidden bias, but change takes time. Until then, late-born players must continue to fight against the odds, proving that talent and determination can still triumph over the disadvantages of birth month.

Sources

Outliers Full Book Summary
Do Guys Keep Growing Until Age 25?
Relative Age Effect Among the Best Norwegian Track and Field Athletes of All Time: Comparisons of Explosive and Endurance Events
Relative Age Effect
How important is the birth date in football players’ sports career?
Malcolm Gladwell: Full Exclusive Interview - No Small Endeavor
Are European Soccer Players Worth More If They Are Born Early in the Year? Relative Age Effect on Player Market Value
Birth Advantages in Male Italian Soccer: How They Influence Players Youth Career and Their Future Career Status
Maturity-Associated Polygenic Profiles of under 12–16-Compared to under 17–23-Year-Old Male English Academy Football Players
How a footballer’s birth month can affect their chances of reaching the top
Study reveals birth month impact on soccer careers
Relative age effect:a serious problem in football
The relative age effect is larger in Italian soccer top-level youth categories and smaller in Serie A
Matthew Effect | Definition & Application
Belgium are much more than a golden generation and it is not luck
The curious tale of the football international nobody ever heard of (because he was born in the wrong month)
“Is early reliable TID possible? No. Is it necessary? No, it is not.” - Prof Dr Arne Güllich