Sort: Trending
Part 1/9:
The Tragic Accident of American Airlines Flight 191
On May 25, 1979, American Airlines Flight 191 faced a catastrophic accident, which, after only 50 seconds in the air, resulted in the deaths of all 271 individuals on board. This incident stands as the worst single-aircraft accident in American aviation history, but what transpired that fateful day had roots that stretched back nearly four years.
The Precursor to Disaster
Part 2/9:
The story of Flight 191 began on May 30, 1975, when McDonnell Douglas issued a service bulletin recommending the replacement of spherical bearings in the aft engine pylon of their DC-10 aircraft. The DC-10, known for its three engines - two mounted on the wings and one in the rear - required significant maintenance to ensure safety. Although the service bulletin outlined necessary repairs, it left implementation to the discretion of the airlines, creating the potential for oversight.
Part 3/9:
American Airlines, along with other major operators like Continental and United, decided to modify the standard procedure by removing the engine and pylon as a single unit using forklifts. This method, while saving time and maintenance effort, raised safety concerns among McDonnell Douglas representatives who warned about potential hazards with such a procedure. However, airlines operated under a system that allowed considerable autonomy for their internal maintenance protocols, meaning there was little oversight of these modified procedures.
Unfolding Events
Part 4/9:
Between March 29 and March 31, 1979, Flight 191 underwent maintenance in Tulsa, Oklahoma. During this inspection, maintenance crew members deviated from prescribed procedures, detaching the aft attachment point before the forward one even after noticing it had made contact with the wing. Following this alteration, the pylon was reattached with a potentially critical stress fracture undetected.
As the weeks passed leading up to the flight, this fracture worsened. By the day of the accident, the aircraft was ready for its scheduled flight from Chicago O'Hare to Los Angeles. It was crewed by an experienced team: Captain Walter Lux, First Officer James Dillard, and Flight Engineer Alfred Udwich.
Part 5/9:
The flight's pre-takeoff checks revealed no maintenance issues, and weather conditions were clear. Unfortunately, the underlying mechanical strains had already begun to take their toll.
The Fateful Takeoff
At 3:02 PM, as the aircraft raced down the runway, the once-sturdy attachment point on the left engine experienced a catastrophic failure. The engine detached dramatically, witnessed by spectators as vaporized hydraulic fluid sprayed into the air. This detachment resulted in extensive damage, severing hydraulic and electrical lines, and forcing the aircraft into an abnormal flight state.
Part 6/9:
Despite losing one engine, the crew attempted to maintain control. The pilots knew well how to manage an engine failure, but the loss of hydraulic systems meant the left wing's leading edge slats could retract uncontrollably, drastically affecting lift and creating an imbalance that rendered the aircraft unstable.
The Final Moments
As the aircraft climbed, its airspeed began to fall dangerously close to the stall threshold of the left wing. Lacking crucial instrumentation due to the engine's failure, the pilots remained unaware they were pitching for an insufficient airspeed to maintain flight. The left wing entered a stall, leading the aircraft to roll left and pitch down uncontrollably.
Part 7/9:
The crew's standard procedures could not avert the impending crash. Within seconds, Flight 191 plunged into a field, killing all aboard and two individuals on the ground. The wreckage was extensive, destroying nearby structures and marking a tragedy that would resonate throughout the aviation industry.
Investigation and Consequences
The National Transportation Safety Board's investigation quickly focused on the root causes of the accident: the failure of the engine to remain attached to the wing and the inability of the crew to regain control following the detachment. Findings revealed the profound implications of maintenance decisions that prioritized efficiency over safety, as seen in the approach taken for replacing the engine and pylon.
Part 8/9:
Further scrutiny revealed similar faults in other DC-10s, yet neither manufacturers nor airline personnel had fully acknowledged the potential risks posed by the maintenance procedure. While investigations cleared the flight crew of any blame, the reputation of the DC-10 was irreparably damaged, leading to reduced public confidence in the aircraft model.
Lessons Learned
The aftermath of Flight 191 brought significant changes to airline safety procedures. The necessity for reporting maintenance issues, analyzing new procedures for potential risks, and establishing mandatory stick shakers became clear. These improvements have since enhanced aviation safety protocols and protected future generations of passengers.
Part 9/9:
In reflecting on this tragic event, the story of American Airlines Flight 191 is both a cautionary tale and a pivotal moment in aviation history, underscoring the importance of diligent maintenance practices and rigorous safety standards.