I stumbled across this article about a married couple who travelled from Cornwall to Manchester via Spain because the flights and one night in a hotel were cheaper than the train fairs...
They were en-route to pick up a new car and needed both of them for the long drive back, I'm not sure this would have been economic with a hotel stay if it was just for one of them.
This whole affair has been used to highlight how expensive trains are compared to planes, but this is an EXTREME case, given that it's one of those rare occasions where you need a journey to be one way, so it's not fair comparing flights with trains. Flights are often priced one way and then nearly double for the return, especially with short-haul, train journeys often charge you 10 pence more for a return.
Then again maybe that highlights a weakness in the train's pricing structure...?
The folly of long distance day travel....
At a deeper level it reminds me of the simply folly of long distance day travel....
I did a hypothetical look for flights from London to Edinburgh...
Sure enough cheaper than the train, which was quoting me double that, with Trainline failing to find me ANY deals for ANY TIME, the site not behaving, another stress. I couldn't actually tell whether there were better deals or not!
and then this old chestnut with Easy Jet...
Yes this means you have to spend another 10 minutes reading their baggage policy unless yer happy to just take a tiny rucksack for the weekend.
I was only digging around to to a hypothetical comparison and just the stress in my shoulders this caused and that's when I'm NOT going anywhere!
I'm either driving or staying put or....
Journey for the sake of the journey, as in, pile in a mobile home and drift, then the journey is the point, but if it's not either a round trip or a very long one-way trip and then a flight back after MONTHS or YEARS, then I'm not getting on a train or plane every again if I can help it.
Just the stress of booking is too much, I'll drive any day of the week thankyou very much!
Oh, and they should have just paid someone else to drive the car back....
I mean it'd be a long day's work plus a train fair for someone, why not just pay them to do it and have the time back for two people?
Now that would have been sensible~!