First thoughts on Splinterland's Land (Secret of Praetoria)

in #hive-133232 years ago

So the Splinterland's Land whitepaper finally came out yesterday... The Secret of Praetoria and there is a LOT of dynamics to take in.

I'm focussing here on just my initial reaction to some of the main points, i.e. what it will mean for me as a TRACT holder (100 plots) and what I'll need to manage my land going forwards.

Land Surveys and Starter Packages

Thankfully we managed to veto the insulting proposal that investors spend yet more DEC to boos their changes of getting a Legendary plot during the survey stage, so that just is what it is - for free and with the same percentage chance of getting a Legendary, Epic, Rare or Common plot.

Personally I'd like to see a guarantee of getting at least one Legendary plot for having a Tract but I don't think that's in the proposal anywhere?!

There are THREE Starter Packages - Building in a Box, Time Vault and Unstable Totem

These may be prettified gamified assets but they all just essentially give you boosts to production in the early phases of gameplay.

And let's face it - this is glorfied DEFI with perty NFTs BUT the early days are when the prices of whatever perty resources are produced are going to have the highest value, and the it's downhill forever after.

So I think buying all three for every plot you have working is going to be worth it.

These are 10K a pop so that's 30K per plot, and 1.5M DEC potentially for 50 plots - I'm aiming for half initially.

Power Sources and DEC staking

Summoners have been sacked off and in place we have Power Batteries - these are 5K a pop, but including in the Building in a Box, so no extra cost there which makes that starter package worth it IMO!

Screenshot 2023-03-18 at 12.56.06.png

And we'll also need DEC to stake.... 50K per plot for max cards...

Screenshot 2023-03-18 at 12.56.36.png

So for 50 plots that is 2.5M DEC.

That total amount of DEC - 4M is doable pretty easily for me by the time land is released, it should just stack from the rentals I've got... BUT it doesn't inspire me to buy more cards... I'd rather make sure I've got the DEC in waiting ready for LAND, it also makes buying DEC batteries for the early stages appealing.

Card Power

Higher CP cards yield massive boosts to production time....

A gold legendary is 10 times as efficient as a regular common, this isn't as much as I'd expected, but the trend is certainly there.

Screenshot 2023-03-18 at 12.57.16.png

No role for SPS

I feel we've been a bit mugged of with SPS on the back of this white paper - it has absolutely NO functionality, in fact it's the other way around - you can specify that monsters mine SPS.

I'm sure we were told (misinformed) that SPS would play a significant role in Land staking.... but no we've been blindsided here.

Final thoughts...

There is a lot more to land than what's above, in fact it all seems quite complex, but I guess there are several stages being gone into.

Overall it's about 60% of what I expected, RUNI seem like a very good buy as they provide a 100% boost to all monsters if staked to one plot.

I am VERY disappointed to not see summoners or SPS providing any production boosts I would have thought these would be natural partners for such functionality from a purely gaming perspective.

But this is all very complex!

Overall not a bad WP, it holds together.

Sort:  

Thanks for the summary. Lots to unpack by the looks of things.

Kinda glad I've only got one plot...

Oh this is just the beginning, there's a lot more!

If all the land in the game is been working on, there won't be enough dec and to create dec you have to burn sps.

It is a good thing for sps

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Fair point!

No utility for Summoners on Land is disappointing and quite possibly misleading after hearing about them being mandatory for a better part of last year.

Yup - it's not great - wld be an obvious move from a game pspctve too just makes sense!

I really agree with you that early days are most important. It is inclusive of before the land go-live.
Due to this WP, Runi price has been raised.

I'm really wondering if I should sold Runi before it comes to downhill. but it is too late since I'm getting loving my Runi..

I wouldn't sell based on this, going to be useful for land based on the looks of it! I've got one I know, or was it two, I can't even remember now!

Oh then need 98 or 99 more Runi are required lol
Hope all of Splinterlands related asset will affect nicely each other.

Yeah I think it's too late for me with the Runi!

No summoners sucks. It was stated they were needed per plot. I bought many, now they are idling around, drinking my beer and getting pissed every day in my wallet.

There were no promises made but allusions, they should have just kept quiet, because allusions are misleading.

Basically very wrong on their part. Same with the statement I remember about SPS being a major part of Land.

My faith in this project is starting to crack, I have a few RL friends who are quite negative about it, maybe I should start listening and focusing more on HIVE.

I know what you mean!

They have really spun this out and always seem to be after more of our money. I have a couple of land plots that are not doing anything for me yet. I think I'll invest my funds elsewhere.

Always after more of our money

Yes. It's now pay to play, and pay a lot to play.

invest elsewhere

Practically every development over the last year has made me glad of every cent I've skimmed out the game on the way, for sure!

I mean it's not a total disaster of a white paper but not that encouraging either. It doesn't encourage me to panic sell, maybe skim a little harder.

I have not read the white paper yet, but making land so complex makes it hard for adoption of new players. I also think the prices seem pretty high. I guess it's a good time to buy DEC because players are going to need a lot of it.